Yes Riverrat, but everything I have ever done with bees has been a lesson learned, I'm on my own a lot with the bees and used to casualties. However, this year during the swarming episode I actually gained positive knowledge, because I had soo many people here helping me out, You included

and now have 3 more hives to boot

so I am three steps ahead.
When the swarming was happening, hubby used the Bissel hand vac, but he only vacuumed for a minute or two max, and then gently dumped the bees into the hive and the bees were just fine. I realize that it was the 'over' vacuuming that was destructive to this hive. In time, if I become a bee catcher, I will invest in a vac like Robo's
And actually, I've read quite a bit from other new keeps on this forum that did their first cut outs and did pretty darned good. It would have been simply terrific if I had a mentor over my shoulder on this one, but it wasn't in the cards, so I watched a lot of Scott's and JP's videos. That is what most of us newbee's have, video's.
Have to have a sit down with Phill and see how he wants to proceed.
1. Either buy a queen $75, add pulled frames
2. Combine and give him a split next spring
3. Add some eggs and a couple of pulled frames and hope that we have a nice loong indian summer